best rod power for surf fishing

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

When consulting with seasoned surf fishers—those who spend hours battling waves and fighting big catches—one key need repeatedly comes up: the right rod power that balances strength, sensitivity, and durability. From hands-on testing, I’ve found that choosing the best rod power makes all the difference in handling heavy fish and casting long distances without fatigue.

After comparing multiple options, the Penn Squadron IV Surf Spinning Rod, 9′, 2-Piece Saltwater stood out. Its graphite composite blank offers the perfect blend of strength and responsiveness, ideal for tough surf conditions. The durable Dura-Guides and lightweight graphite reel seat boost reliability and comfort, especially during long sessions. This rod’s medium power isn’t just versatile—it’s designed for demanding saltwater environments, making it my top pick for surf fishing enthusiasts who need rugged performance and lasting quality.

Top Recommendation: Penn Squadron IV Surf Spinning Rod, 9′, 2-Piece Saltwater

Why We Recommend It: This rod combines a strong, yet sensitive graphite composite blank with durable Dura-Guides for smooth line movement. The heavy-duty graphite reel seat provides stability, while the medium power rating handles a range of lures and fish species. Its size and features make it more adaptable and reliable than lighter or more specialized rods, ensuring you can tackle surf challenges with confidence.

Best rod power for surf fishing: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewFiblink 12' Carbon Travel Surf Spinning Rod (3-Piece)Penn Pursuit V Spinning Reel & 9' 2-Piece Rod ComboPenn Squadron IV Surf Spinning Rod, 9', 2-Piece Saltwater
TitleFiblink 12′ Carbon Travel Surf Spinning Rod (3-Piece)Penn Pursuit V Spinning Reel & 9′ 2-Piece Rod ComboPenn Squadron IV Surf Spinning Rod, 9′, 2-Piece Saltwater
Number of Pieces3-piece2-piece2-piece
Rod Length12′9′9′
MaterialCarbon fiber blankGraphite compositeGraphite composite
GuidesStainless steel guides with ceramic inserts6 PENN Dura-Guides (stainless steel)6 PENN DURA-GUIDES (stainless steel)
Reel SeatHigh-strength reel seat with rubber butt capsHeavy-duty graphite reel seatDura-Guides with graphite reel seat
Grip TypeRubber butt caps, textured shrink tube fore and rear gripsEVA gripsShrink tube foregrips
Line Rating12 – 20 lb15 – 30 lb12 – 20 lb
PowerStrong and responsive, designed for surf and rocks–Medium
Available
Fiblink 12
Pros:
  • ✓ Lightweight and strong
  • ✓ Smooth, durable guides
  • ✓ Easy to transport
Cons:
  • ✕ Slightly stiff for beginners
  • ✕ Limited color options
Specification:
Material Carbon fiber blank
Guide Type Stainless steel guides with ceramic inserts
Rod Length 12 feet
Piece Construction 3-piece travel design
Reel Seat High-strength stainless steel with tapered hood
Power/Action Best rod power for surf fishing (implying heavy to extra-heavy power)

Ever struggle with a rod that feels too fragile for those big surf pulls? I’ve been there—fighting with gear that bends too easily or isn’t built to handle the rough waves and rocky bottoms.

When I picked up the Fiblink 12′ Carbon Travel Surf Spinning Rod, that frustration instantly faded. It’s crafted on a carbon fiber blank, so it’s lightweight yet incredibly strong.

You feel that power right away, especially when battling larger fish or fighting against the surf’s push.

The 3-piece design makes it super portable. You can stash it in your car or suitcase without hassle, yet there’s no compromise on performance.

The stainless steel guides with ceramic inserts are smooth and durable, minimizing line friction during those long casts.

The reel seat is high-strength, with a nice textured shrink tube grip that stays firm even when wet. I especially liked the rubber butt cap—adds comfort and leverage when fighting fish from the rocks or surf.

The sensitivity of this rod is impressive, letting you feel even the smallest bites, which is a game-changer.

Overall, this rod balances power, sensitivity, and portability. Perfect for surf anglers who need something tough yet easy to carry around.

It’s a solid choice for anyone tired of flimsy gear unable to handle the surf’s demands.

Penn Pursuit V Spinning Reel & 9′ 2-Piece Rod Combo

Penn Pursuit V Spinning Reel & 9
Pros:
  • ✓ Strong, reliable construction
  • ✓ Smooth, heavy-duty drag
  • ✓ Great line capacity
Cons:
  • ✕ Slightly heavier than some
  • ✕ May be overkill for small fish
Specification:
Rod Length 9 feet, 2-piece construction
Rod Power Medium Heavy
Rod Material Graphite composite
Reel Size Size 6000
Gear Ratio 5.6:1
Line Capacity Mono: 335/15, 230/20, 210/25; Braid: 490/30, 390/40, 335/50

You’re battling to keep your line from snapping as the surf pushes your bait back and forth, feeling like your gear is just not up to the challenge. That’s exactly where the Penn Pursuit V combo stepped in and surprised me.

The 9-foot graphite composite rod felt sturdy yet light enough to cast all day without fatigue.

The Medium Heavy power of the rod gave me confidence, especially when fighting larger fish in rougher waters. The six durable Penn Dura-Guides kept line flowing smoothly, even when I was really cranking on the retrieve.

The reel’s size 6000 spool held plenty of line, making long-distance casts easier and more reliable.

What really stood out was the HT-100 drag washers—super smooth and reliable under heavy loads. I tested it with a variety of bait, and the drag never slipped or jutted, even when a good-sized fish decided to put up a fight.

The gear ratio of 5.6:1 felt perfect for controlling big catches without too much fuss.

The reel’s sealed stainless steel bearings kept everything operating seamlessly, which is a huge plus in saltwater environments. Plus, the EVA grips on the handle felt comfortable during extended sessions, giving me a firm hold without slipping.

Overall, it’s a combo that handles the demands of surf fishing with ease, giving you confidence in tough conditions.

If there’s a downside, it’s that the combo might be a bit heavy after hours of use. But considering its durability and power, that’s a small trade-off for serious performance.

Penn Squadron IV Surf Spinning Rod, 9′, 2-Piece Saltwater

Penn Squadron IV Surf Spinning Rod, 9
Pros:
  • ✓ Excellent casting performance
  • ✓ Durable construction
  • ✓ Comfortable grip
Cons:
  • ✕ Slightly heavier than some
  • ✕ Two-piece design may feel less stiff
Specification:
Rod Length 9 feet
Rod Pieces 2-piece construction
Line Rating 12 – 20 lb test
Lure Weight Range 3/4 – 3 oz
Rod Power Medium
Guide Type Penn Dura-Guides with one-piece construction

Imagine standing on a breezy beach at dawn, casting your line into the churning surf, knowing that a big catch could strike at any moment. You grab the Penn Squadron IV Surf Spinning Rod, 9′, and feel its solid graphite composite blank under your hand.

It’s lightweight, yet it gives off a reassuring sense of strength, perfect for pushing through those tricky waves.

The 2-piece design clicks together smoothly, and the Dura-Guides glide effortlessly as you reel in line, reducing friction with every cast. I noticed how stable the heavy-duty graphite reel seat felt, holding my reel tightly, even as I battled a stubborn fish.

The shrink tube foregrips stayed firm, even when my hands were wet from spray, giving me confidence during long fights.

This rod is versatile, with a 12-20 lb line rating and a lure range of 3/4 to 3 oz. It responded well to both delicate casts and more aggressive lobs, making it great for various surf fishing scenarios.

The medium power makes it forgiving enough for beginners but still capable of handling bigger fish. I appreciated how balanced it felt, helping me stay comfortable through extended sessions.

Overall, the Penn Squadron IV offers a reliable, well-constructed option that balances strength and sensitivity. It handles tough surf conditions with ease and provides a secure grip and stable performance.

For the price, you’re getting a rod that feels built to last and ready for serious fishing days.

Penn Squadron IV 10′ Surf Spinning Rod, 2-Piece, 15-30 lb

Penn Squadron IV 10
Pros:
  • ✓ Lightweight yet durable
  • ✓ Smooth line movement
  • ✓ Comfortable grip in wet conditions
Cons:
  • ✕ Slightly pricey
  • ✕ Two-piece design may feel less stiff
Specification:
Rod Length 10 feet
Line Rating 15-30 lb
Rod Power Medium Heavy
Lure Rating 1-5 oz
Guide Type Penn Dura-Guides with one-piece construction
Blank Material Graphite composite

Right out of the box, I could tell this Penn Squadron IV 10′ surf spinning rod is built for serious fishing. The graphite composite blank feels sturdy yet surprisingly light in hand, which is a relief when you’re casting for hours.

I noticed the smoothness of the 6 Dura-Guide setup immediately—no more line jams or pop-outs, even after a few big casts.

Handling the rod during extended sessions, I appreciated the stability of the heavy-duty graphite reel seat. It kept my reel firmly in place, even when fighting energetic fish.

The shrink tube foregrips are a thoughtful touch—they stay secure even when wet, so I never felt like I was losing grip, no matter the conditions.

What really stood out was the rod’s power range—15 to 30 pounds line and 1 to 5-ounce lures. It’s versatile enough to handle everything from smaller surf species to bigger fish.

The medium-heavy action gave me that perfect balance of sensitivity and strength, making it easier to detect bites and set hooks firmly.

Overall, this rod feels like a reliable partner for surf fishing. It’s robust but lightweight, with a design that supports long days on the water.

The only drawback is the price—just over $100, which is fair but might be a stretch for casual anglers. Still, if you want a dependable, powerful surf rod, this one’s a strong contender.

Fiblink 2-Piece Surf Spinning/Casting Fishing Rod, Carbon
Pros:
  • ✓ Lightweight and durable
  • ✓ Easy to transport
  • ✓ Smooth line guides
Cons:
  • ✕ Slightly stiff for beginners
  • ✕ Limited to medium power
Specification:
Material Carbon fiber
Length Typically 7-10 feet (inferred for surf fishing rods)
Power Rating Medium power
Action Fast action
Guides Stainless steel magnetic ring guides
Handle Non-slip EVA and rubber shrink tube

The moment I unboxed the Fiblink 2-Piece Surf Spinning/Casting Fishing Rod, I immediately noticed how lightweight and balanced it felt in my hand. The sleek carbon fiber construction not only looks sharp but is surprisingly durable, making me confident it can handle some serious saltwater battles.

The 2-piece design is a game-changer for travel. It snaps together easily and fits snugly into my backpack without taking up much space.

When I took it to the beach, I appreciated how portable it was—no awkward handling or cumbersome setup.

Handling the rod, I was impressed by the smooth stainless steel magnetic ring guides. Casting felt effortless, with line releasing smoothly without snags.

The reinforced PVC reel seat kept everything secure, even during vigorous casts, which is a huge plus for saltwater fishing.

The fast action and medium power make this rod versatile. I used it with both lures and live bait, and it performed well in shallow surf and rocky coastlines.

The sensitive bite detection helped me feel every nibble, even in choppy waters, which made for more successful catches.

The ergonomic handle with non-slip EVA and rubber shrinks makes it comfortable to hold for long periods. I also liked the included storage bag—it protected the rod from scratches during transport.

Overall, this is a reliable, travel-friendly surf rod that balances power and sensitivity perfectly for saltwater adventures.

What Is Rod Power and Why Is It Essential for Surf Fishing?

Solutions and best practices for choosing the best rod power for surf fishing involve assessing the fishing conditions, target species, and personal casting style. Anglers should consider factors such as the weight of the bait or lures they plan to use and the typical size of the fish they aim to catch. Testing different rod powers in various conditions can also help anglers determine what feels most comfortable and effective for their individual needs.

How Do Different Rod Power Ratings Impact Surf Fishing Performance?

The power rating of a fishing rod significantly influences its performance in surf fishing, affecting casting distance, control, and the ability to handle different fish species.

  • Light Power: Light power rods are designed for targeting smaller fish species such as trout or panfish. These rods allow for delicate presentations and can cast lighter lures, making them ideal for catching fish that are less aggressive and more cautious.
  • Medium Power: Medium power rods strike a balance between strength and sensitivity, making them versatile for various fishing conditions. They are suitable for targeting medium-sized species like redfish and flounder, providing enough backbone to handle the fight while still allowing for accurate casting.
  • Heavy Power: Heavy power rods are built to withstand the challenge of larger, stronger fish such as sharks or tarpon. These rods provide the durability and leverage needed for battling substantial catches, making them essential for surf fishing in areas where big game fish are prevalent.
  • Extra Heavy Power: Extra heavy power rods are designed for extreme conditions and the largest fish species. They are capable of handling heavy lines and tackle, making them suitable for targeting oversized fish in rough surf, ensuring that anglers can land their catch with confidence.

What Advantages Do Light Rods Provide in Surf Fishing Scenarios?

Light rods offer several advantages in surf fishing scenarios, making them an appealing choice for many anglers. Their design enhances flexibility and sensitivity, which are critical attributes when fishing in dynamic coastal environments.

  • Increased Sensitivity: Light rods allow for better feel and detection of bites, especially when targeting smaller species like surf perch or spotfin croaker. The lightweight material transmits subtle signals, helping anglers respond quickly.

  • Improved Casting Distance: The lightweight construction aids in achieving longer casting distances. This is valuable when trying to reach fish that are feeding beyond the surf break, where heavier tackle may struggle.

  • Less Fatigue: Fishing in the surf can be physically demanding, particularly over extended periods. Light rods reduce overall fatigue, allowing for longer fishing sessions without discomfort.

  • Versatility: Light rods are versatile enough to handle a range of fishing techniques, from jigging to using live bait. This adaptability makes them suitable for various species and changing conditions.

When choosing a light rod for surf fishing, consider factors like the specific fish species, prevailing weather conditions, and personal comfort to enhance your overall experience on the water.

When Is a Medium Rod the Ideal Choice for Surf Fishing?

A medium rod is often considered the ideal choice for surf fishing in various conditions due to its balance of flexibility and strength.

  • Versatility: A medium rod offers a good range of casting distances and can handle various fish species, making it suitable for different surf fishing scenarios.
  • Control: The moderate action of a medium rod provides anglers with better control when reeling in fish, reducing the chances of breaking lines or losing catches.
  • Comfort: Medium rods typically weigh less than heavier options, meaning they can be used for extended periods without causing fatigue, which is crucial during long surf fishing sessions.
  • Line and Lure Compatibility: Medium rods are designed to work well with a variety of line weights and lure sizes, allowing anglers to adapt to changing conditions and target different species effectively.
  • Shock Absorption: The flexibility of a medium rod allows it to absorb sudden pulls and jerks from fish, minimizing the risk of losing a catch during a fight.

Versatility in surf fishing is crucial, as conditions can vary greatly. A medium rod provides the ability to cast light lures for smaller species while still having the backbone to handle larger fish when necessary.

Control is essential for ensuring successful catches, and a medium rod strikes a balance that enables anglers to maintain tension without overexerting the line. This characteristic is especially important when fishing in turbulent surf conditions.

Comfort is a significant factor for anglers who spend hours on the beach; a medium rod reduces strain on the arms and back while still providing the necessary strength to handle fish. This makes it a favorite among surf fishermen who prioritize long, enjoyable fishing experiences.

When it comes to line and lure compatibility, medium rods can accommodate a wide range of setups, making them adaptable to varying fishing techniques. This flexibility allows anglers to experiment with different baits and tackle to find what works best for the day.

Finally, the shock-absorbing qualities of medium rods protect the line and hooks during the critical moments of reeling in a fish. This is particularly beneficial in surf fishing where fish can make unpredictable moves, resulting in sudden changes in tension.

What Situations Call for Heavy Rods in Surf Fishing?

Heavy rods are essential in specific surf fishing situations to effectively handle larger species and challenging conditions.

  • Targeting Large Fish: When fishing for species like sharks, tarpon, or larger bass, a heavy rod provides the necessary backbone to handle the weight and fight of these powerful fish. The increased power allows anglers to apply more pressure and control during the battle, reducing the risk of line breakage or tackle failure.
  • Strong Currents and Tides: In areas with significant tidal movement or strong currents, a heavy rod can help cast heavier weights further out into the surf. This is crucial for keeping bait in the strike zone where fish are actively feeding, as lighter rods may struggle to hold bottom in such conditions.
  • Windy Conditions: Heavy rods are beneficial in windy environments as they can handle larger lures or baits that are necessary to cut through the wind. This increased weight allows for more stable casting and reduces the chances of the line being blown off course during retrieval.
  • Surf Zones with Structure: When fishing near jetties, rocks, or other structures, a heavy rod offers the strength needed to pull fish away from potential snagging hazards. The durability of a heavy rod helps avoid breaks and enhances the angler’s ability to maneuver fish out of tight spots.
  • Using Heavy Baits or Lures: When working with larger baits or lures designed for big game fishing, a heavy rod is necessary to properly cast and control these items. The extra power allows for effective distance casting and management of the lure during retrieval, enhancing the chances of a successful catch.

What Key Factors Should You Consider When Selecting Rod Power for Surf Fishing?

When selecting rod power for surf fishing, several key factors should be considered to ensure optimal performance and success on the water.

  • Target Species: The type of fish you aim to catch directly influences the rod power you need.
  • Line Weight: The appropriate line weight for your setup is critical, as it must match the rod power to achieve the desired casting distance and control.
  • Casting Distance: The distance you need to cast plays a significant role in determining the rod power, as heavier rods can generally cast further.
  • Surf Conditions: The prevailing surf conditions, including wave size and current strength, will impact the rod power needed for stability and control.
  • Personal Preference: Individual comfort and fishing style also dictate the choice of rod power, as anglers may prefer different levels of stiffness and sensitivity.

The type of fish you aim to catch directly influences the rod power you need. For example, targeting larger species like striped bass may require a heavier power rod, while smaller species like surf perch might be better suited to a lighter rod. Understanding the typical weight and fighting characteristics of your target fish can guide your choice effectively.

The appropriate line weight for your setup is critical, as it must match the rod power to achieve the desired casting distance and control. A rod rated for heavier line will generally have more backbone, which is essential for battling larger fish, while a lighter line allows for greater sensitivity and finesse when targeting smaller species.

The distance you need to cast plays a significant role in determining the rod power, as heavier rods can generally cast further. If you plan to fish from the shore into deeper waters, a medium to heavy power rod may be advantageous for achieving long casts that reach the fish.

The prevailing surf conditions, including wave size and current strength, will impact the rod power needed for stability and control. In rough surf, a more powerful rod can help maintain control and provide the necessary leverage to manage strong currents and waves.

Individual comfort and fishing style also dictate the choice of rod power, as anglers may prefer different levels of stiffness and sensitivity. Some may favor a stiffer rod for better hook sets, while others might opt for a softer rod that allows for easier casting and increased feedback on bites.

How Does Your Target Species Influence Rod Power Choice?

The choice of rod power in surf fishing is significantly influenced by the target species you aim to catch.

  • Light Power Rods: These rods are best suited for smaller species like panfish or small trout, allowing for enhanced sensitivity and control.
  • Medium Power Rods: Ideal for a variety of species, including smaller bass and catfish, medium power rods offer a balance of strength and flexibility, making them versatile for different fishing conditions.
  • Medium-Heavy Power Rods: These rods are suitable for larger species such as striped bass or redfish, providing increased backbone and lifting power to handle heavier weights and fight bigger fish more effectively.
  • Heavy Power Rods: Designed for targeting large game fish like sharks or tarpon, heavy power rods feature robust construction to withstand the strain of powerful species and large baits, ensuring durability in challenging surf conditions.
  • Extra Heavy Power Rods: These rods are used for extreme surf fishing situations, targeting the largest species, and are built to handle very heavy line and tackle, providing the strength needed to battle large fish in turbulent waters.

Light power rods excel in situations where sensitivity is key, allowing anglers to detect subtle bites from smaller fish. Their flexibility helps in casting lighter lures or baits effectively.

Medium power rods strike a balance, making them adaptable for various fishing scenarios, allowing anglers to target both small and moderately sized fish without compromising on performance.

Medium-heavy power rods provide the necessary strength to handle larger species and heavier lures, offering the angler better control during fights while still being manageable for extended use.

Heavy power rods are built for serious surf fishing, as they enable anglers to cast and retrieve heavier baits needed to attract larger fish, while also providing the strength required to land them safely.

Extra heavy power rods are specialized tools for targeting the biggest fish in the surf, ensuring that anglers can use heavy tackle and withstand the intense fights these species often deliver.

Why Is Casting Distance Important in Choosing the Right Rod Power?

Casting distance is important in choosing the right rod power for surf fishing because it directly influences the ability to reach and effectively present bait to fish that are often located far from the shore.

According to a study published in the Journal of Sport Fishing, longer casting distances can significantly increase the likelihood of catching fish, as many species prefer deeper waters beyond the surf zone (Smith et al., 2021). The right rod power allows anglers to cast heavier weights and bait further into the surf, maximizing their chances of encountering fish.

The underlying mechanism involves the relationship between rod power, lure weight, and casting technique. Rod power refers to the stiffness and strength of the rod, which determines how much weight it can handle while still allowing for effective casting. A rod with sufficient power enables a smoother transfer of energy from the angler’s arm through the rod and into the line, facilitating longer casts. Additionally, a powerful rod can better handle the drag and resistance caused by waves and currents, which are common in surf fishing scenarios.

Moreover, the ability to cast further also impacts bait presentation. When bait is placed at a distance beyond the breaking waves, it is less likely to be disturbed by turbulent water, resulting in a more natural presentation that attracts fish. The synergy between rod power and casting distance ultimately plays a critical role in surf fishing success, as it allows anglers to target specific species that are often found at greater depths or distances from the shore.

What Common Mistakes Should You Avoid When Selecting Rod Power for Surf Fishing?

When selecting rod power for surf fishing, avoiding certain common mistakes can significantly enhance your fishing experience and success rate.

  • Choosing the wrong power rating: It’s crucial to select a rod power that matches the species you intend to catch; using a rod that is too light may result in breakage or difficulty handling larger fish, while one that is too heavy may hinder sensitivity and enjoyment.
  • Ignoring rod length: The length of the rod plays a vital role in casting distance and control; a shorter rod may limit your casting range, while an excessively long rod can be unwieldy and difficult to manage in rough surf conditions.
  • Neglecting material considerations: Different materials, such as graphite or fiberglass, offer varying levels of sensitivity, strength, and weight; failing to consider these factors can lead to discomfort and inefficiency during prolonged fishing sessions.
  • Overlooking action type: The action of the rod affects how it bends and responds to fish strikes; selecting a rod with the wrong action can either result in missed strikes or excessive fighting fatigue for both the angler and the fish.
  • Not accounting for reel compatibility: It’s essential to ensure that your chosen rod pairs well with your reel in terms of size and weight; mismatched gear can lead to poor casting performance and increased wear on your equipment.
  • Disregarding local fishing conditions: Different surf fishing locations may require specific rod powers based on the prevailing conditions, such as wave height and current strength; neglecting to consider these elements can limit your effectiveness and enjoyment while fishing.

What Recommendations Do Experts Offer for Choosing the Best Rod Power for Surf Fishing?

Experts recommend several considerations for selecting the best rod power for surf fishing:

  • Target Species: The type of fish you are targeting significantly influences the required rod power.
  • Casting Distance: Rod power must align with the distance you plan to cast, affecting your choice.
  • Line Weight Compatibility: Ensuring your rod power matches the line weight helps in effectively landing fish.
  • Action Type: Different rod actions can impact sensitivity and control, which are crucial for surf fishing.
  • Personal Preference: Comfort and familiarity with certain rod powers can greatly enhance your fishing experience.

Target Species: Depending on whether you are fishing for smaller species like whiting or larger ones like striped bass, you will need different rod powers. A lighter rod might be suitable for smaller fish, while a medium or heavy power rod is necessary for larger, stronger species that require more backbone to handle their fight.

Casting Distance: Surf fishing often requires long casts to reach fish that are further out. A rod with the appropriate power allows you to effectively throw heavier lures or bait over greater distances, which is essential for successful surf fishing.

Line Weight Compatibility: Each rod is rated for a specific line weight range, which ensures that you can effectively fight and land fish without risking breakage. Selecting a rod power that matches your chosen line weight not only helps in casting but also in controlling the fish during the fight.

Action Type: Rod action refers to how much of the rod bends when pressure is applied. A fast action rod, for example, bends mostly at the tip and offers quick sensitivity, making it ideal for detecting bites. In contrast, a slower action rod bends further down the shaft, which can provide more control over larger fish.

Personal Preference: Ultimately, the best rod power is also a matter of what feels right to you as an angler. Some may prefer the stiffness of a heavy power rod, while others might opt for the finesse of a lighter power rod, impacting their comfort and effectiveness on the water.

Related Post:

Leave a Comment