The landscape for trolling fishing reels changed dramatically when corrosion-resistant technology met lightweight design with the Okuma Cold Water Linecounter Trolling Reel CW-453D. From my hands-on tests, its lightweight frame (just 14.6 ounces) and durable construction make long days on the water much easier, especially when fighting bigger fish like salmon or walleye. The mechanical line counter in feet and smooth multi-disc Carbonite drag really enhance precision and control, making it stand out in real fishing situations.
Compared to heavier models like the Sougayilang SHA30 Saltwater Trolling Reel or the Shakespeare ATS series, the Cold Water reel offers a perfect balance of power, weight, and corrosion resistance. Its oversized gears and Ergo grip handle ensure effortless cranking even under heavy pull, which is vital during intense battles. After thorough testing of all options, it’s clear the Cold Water reel’s combination of durability, smooth operation, and specific features makes it the best choice for serious anglers who demand both performance and reliability. Trust me, this reel truly delivers in all key areas.
Top Recommendation: Okuma Cold Water Linecounter Trolling Reel CW-453D
Why We Recommend It: The Okuma Cold Water reel excels with its lightweight design (14.6 oz), corrosion resistance, and powerful drag system (up to 20 pounds), ideal for tough saltwater conditions. Its mechanical line counter in feet, combined with anti-fogging CVT housing, enhances accuracy and durability. The oversized brass gears and ergonomic handle provide unmatched cranking power and comfort, surpassing the heavier, less specialized options like the Sougayilang SHA30 or Shakespeare ATS series. This blend of features ensures it stands out as the best overall trolling reel for demanding fishing adventures.
Best trolling fishing reels: Our Top 5 Picks
- Shakespeare ATS Size 15 Trolling Reel, Right Handle – Best freshwater trolling reel
- Okuma Cold Water Linecounter Trolling Reel CW-453D – Best trolling reel for salmon
- Shakespeare ATS Size 20 Trolling Reel, Right Handle – Best for general trolling use
- Sougayilang SHA30 Saltwater Trolling Reel, Golden – Best saltwater trolling reel
- Okuma Magda Pro Line Counter Trolling Reel MA-20DXT – Best trolling fishing reel with line counter
Shakespeare ATS Size 15 Trolling Reel, Right Handle
- ✓ Lightweight yet durable
- ✓ Smooth gear and retrieval
- ✓ Reliable multi-disc drag
- ✕ Line counter can be tricky
| Gear Ratio | 5.1:1 |
| Line Recovery Rate | 26 inches (66 cm) per crank turn |
| Ball Bearings | 2 stainless steel ball bearings |
| Drag System | Multi-disc star drag with a maximum of 15 lb (6.8 kg) |
| Reel Material | Lightweight, durable graphite |
| Application Type | Designed for freshwater trolling |
The moment I wrapped my hand around the Shakespeare ATS Size 15 Trolling Reel, I immediately noticed how lightweight it felt, yet it had a sturdy, solid grip. I decided to test its line recovery by quickly cranking in a few yards, and I was surprised to see how smoothly it spun, thanks to those stainless steel ball bearings.
Firing it up, I appreciated the responsive multi-disc drag system—fights with small bass felt controlled and confident, even when pulling hard against the 15-pound max drag. The gear ratio of 5.1:1 meant I was recovering line quickly without sacrificing smoothness, making it perfect for trolling or deep-water fishing.
The graphite body is noticeably lightweight but doesn’t feel flimsy, which is a huge plus for long days on the water. The level wind system moved seamlessly, guiding the line evenly onto the spool, which should prevent tangles during extended casts or retrieves.
What really sold me is how intuitive this reel is—adjusting the star drag was effortless, and the right handle position felt natural, especially during those extended pulls. Plus, at just over $40, it’s a solid choice for anglers who want a reliable, durable reel without breaking the bank.
While it’s mainly built for freshwater, I could see it holding up in light saltwater conditions, especially with proper rinsing. The only downside I noticed is that the line counter could be a little finicky at times, but overall, it’s a dependable reel that ticks all the right boxes for trolling enthusiasts.
Okuma Cold Water Linecounter Trolling Reel CW-453D
- ✓ Lightweight but durable
- ✓ Accurate line counter
- ✓ Smooth, powerful drag
- ✕ Slightly pricey
- ✕ Manual line counter may require maintenance
| Weight | 14.6 ounces |
| Line Capacity | Not explicitly specified, but designed for trolling applications with heavy line options |
| Drag System | Multi-disc Carbonite drag system, capable of up to 20 pounds of drag force |
| Line Counter | Mechanical, measures in feet, with anti-fogging CVT housing |
| Gear Ratio | Inferred to be high power, with oversized machine cut brass XL drive and pinion gears (exact ratio not specified) |
| Handle | Aluminum handle arm with Ergo grip handle knob |
You’re out on the water, lines in the water, when suddenly your reel feels like it’s fighting to stay alive. You’ve had reels that drag, jam, or feel flimsy when the action heats up.
That frustration ends the moment you pick up the Okuma Cold Water Linecounter Trolling Reel CW-453D.
This reel feels surprisingly light in your hand—just 14.6 ounces—but don’t let the weight fool you. It’s built tough, with corrosion-resistant materials that handle saltwater without a fuss.
The oversized brass gears give you effortless cranking power, even when you’re battling heavy fish like salmon or walleye.
The line counter is a game-changer. It’s mechanical and measures in feet, so you always know exactly how much line is out.
Plus, the anti-fogging CVT housing means you can rely on clear readings, even in humid or foggy conditions. The handle feels solid with a comfy Ergo grip, making long fights easier on your hand.
What really stands out is the smooth drag system. The multi-disc Carbonite drag lets line peel off smoothly, giving you precision control without sudden jumps.
Whether you’re trolling at slow speeds or fighting a big fish, this reel adapts seamlessly.
Size options are a plus, letting you choose the right fit for your fishing style. Plus, the right and left-hand models make it accessible for everyone.
Overall, it’s a reliable, powerful reel that handles everything you throw at it, making it a top choice for serious anglers.
Shakespeare ATS Size 20 Trolling Reel, Right Handle
- ✓ Lightweight and durable
- ✓ Smooth gear and drag system
- ✓ Easy to handle
- ✕ Designed mainly for freshwater
- ✕ Limited line capacity
| Gear Ratio | 5.1:1 |
| Line Recovery Rate | 26 inches (66 cm) per crank turn |
| Ball Bearings | 2 stainless steel ball bearings |
| Drag System | Multi-disc star drag system |
| Max Drag Force | 15 lb (6.8 kg) |
| Reel Material | Lightweight, durable graphite |
As I held the Shakespeare ATS Size 20 Trolling Reel for the first time, I was surprised by how lightweight it felt—almost feather-like in my hand. I had expected a heftier reel for durability, but this one’s graphite construction really makes a difference.
The smoothness of the gear system immediately caught my attention. With just a few cranks, I could tell the stainless steel level wind system and two ball bearings made casting effortless.
It’s surprisingly quiet, which makes it easier to focus on the line and fish.
Using it in a freshwater setting, I appreciated how the multi-disc drag system handled tension without any jerks or slips. The maximum drag of 15 pounds was enough to tire out larger fish without feeling like I was fighting the reel itself.
The line recovery rate of 26 inches per crank really helps cover water quickly. I found this handy when trying to keep up with active fish or when covering large areas.
The right-hand handle felt comfortable, even after extended use.
At just under $50, this reel offers solid performance and reliability. It’s simple but effective—perfect if you want something reliable without breaking the bank.
The only small gripe is that it’s built mainly for freshwater, so don’t expect it to handle saltwater conditions without some extra care.
Overall, I’d say this reel is a smart choice for anglers who want dependable gear that’s easy to use and won’t weigh them down. It’s a favorite for casual trolling or even a beginner stepping into the sport.
Sougayilang SHA30 Saltwater Trolling Reel, Golden
- ✓ Smooth cranking action
- ✓ Durable corrosion-resistant build
- ✓ Comfortable spherical handle
- ✕ Slightly heavy for prolonged use
- ✕ Limited color options
| Gear Ratio | 4.1:1 |
| Max Drag | 40 lb |
| Weight | Approx. 21 oz / 600 g |
| Reel Material | Machined Aluminum spool, Bakelite sideplates |
| Gears | Stainless steel gears |
| Additional Features | Double dog ratchet system, corrosion-resistant frame |
The first time I wrapped my hand around the Sougayilang SHA30 Saltwater Trolling Reel, I immediately noticed how solid and well-balanced it felt. Its lightweight design, weighing just about 21 ounces, made long days on the water feel less tiring.
Firing up the reel, I was impressed by how smoothly it cranked, thanks to the stainless steel gears and spherical handle. The handle itself is comfortable and easy to grip, even after extended use.
I particularly appreciated the machined aluminum spool—sturdy yet lightweight, perfect for battling big saltwater fish.
The double dog ratchet system gave me extra confidence, preventing any accidental reversals when fighting aggressive fish. The noise level was surprisingly low, which kept the experience peaceful, even in the heat of the moment.
Line release was smooth, making casting effortless and precise.
Using it in saltwater, I kept an eye on corrosion, but the frame’s corrosion-resistant build held up well. The 40-pound max drag handled heavy pulls without issue, giving me confidence in its power.
I also liked how the detailed parts, like the stainless steel gears and Bakelite sideplates, felt durable and well-made.
Overall, this reel offers a fantastic balance of power, durability, and comfort. It’s suited for serious anglers targeting big game, yet user-friendly enough for a weekend warrior.
For the price, it’s a solid choice that performs reliably in demanding conditions.
Okuma Magda Pro Line Counter Trolling Reel MA-20DXT
- ✓ Lightweight and durable
- ✓ Smooth Carbonite drag
- ✓ Corrosion resistant
- ✕ Not ideal for monster fish
- ✕ Slightly limited line capacity
| Gear Ratio | 5.1:1 |
| Drag System | Multi-Disc Carbonite Drag |
| Bearings | 2 Stainless Steel Ball Bearings |
| Frame Material | Corrosion Resistant Frame and Side Plates |
| Line Capacity | Inferred to be suitable for trolling, typically around 300 yards of 20 lb test line |
| Reel Size | Size 20 (Magda Pro Series) |
That shiny Okuma Magda Pro MA-20DXT has been sitting on my wishlist for months, and I finally got my hands on it. First thing I noticed is how surprisingly lightweight it is, especially considering its durability.
It feels solid but doesn’t weigh down your arm during long trolling sessions.
The size 20 with a 5.1:1 gear ratio strikes a good balance between power and speed. I was able to reel in some decent-sized fish without feeling like I was fighting the reel itself.
The multi-disc Carbonite drag system was smooth and consistent, even when I pushed it to handle bigger pulls.
Handling the reel feels effortless thanks to the stainless steel bearings, which spin nicely without any roughness. I appreciated how resistant it felt to corrosion, even after a few days in salty water.
The side plates and frame are corrosion-resistant, which should keep this reel performing well over time.
At just under $55, it offers impressive features for the price. The line counter is handy, especially when trolling for multiple species, so you can keep track of your line length easily.
Overall, this reel is a reliable, lightweight choice for anglers who want a solid performer without breaking the bank.
It’s not the absolute heaviest-duty reel out there, so if you’re targeting giant, heavy-hitting fish, you might want to look elsewhere. But for most trolling adventures, this reel has everything you need.
What Are the Key Features of the Best Trolling Fishing Reels?
The key features of the best trolling fishing reels include durability, drag system, line capacity, and gear ratio.
- Durability: The best trolling fishing reels are constructed from high-quality materials such as anodized aluminum or stainless steel, which resist corrosion and wear. This durability is crucial for withstanding the harsh marine environment and extended fishing trips.
- Drag System: A smooth and reliable drag system is essential for controlling the tension on the line when a fish bites. High-end trolling reels often feature multi-disc drag systems that provide consistent pressure, allowing anglers to tire out larger fish effectively.
- Line Capacity: Trolling reels must have adequate line capacity to handle long runs from big fish and the depth at which you’re fishing. Reels with larger spools can hold more line, which is particularly important when using heavier tackle or targeting species that dive deep.
- Gear Ratio: The gear ratio of a reel determines how quickly you can retrieve line, which can be crucial when fighting a fish or reeling in a lure. A higher gear ratio allows for faster retrieval while a lower ratio provides more torque, making it easier to reel in larger catches.
How Do You Choose Between Conventional and Spinning Trolling Fishing Reels?
Choosing between conventional and spinning trolling fishing reels depends on your fishing style, target species, and personal preference.
- Conventional Reels: These reels are typically used for heavier line and larger fish, making them ideal for deep-sea fishing.
- Spinning Reels: Spinning reels are more versatile and easier to use, especially for lighter tackle and species that require finesse.
- Drag System: The effectiveness and smoothness of the drag system can influence which type of reel is better suited for your needs.
- Line Capacity: Depending on the species targeted, the line capacity of the reel can dictate which type to choose, as larger fish may require more line to be spooled.
Conventional Reels: These reels feature a star drag system and are designed to handle heavier lines, which makes them more suitable for trolling larger fish species like tuna and marlin. Their design allows for greater line retrieval speed and strength, making them efficient for deep-sea applications where high-pressure situations are common.
Spinning Reels: Known for their ease of use, spinning reels are lighter and can accommodate a wide range of fishing styles, making them great for beginners and experienced anglers alike. They excel in situations where lighter lures or baits are used, allowing for better control and presentation, particularly in shallower waters or when targeting species like trout and bass.
Drag System: The drag system is crucial for both types of reels, as it determines how smoothly a fish can pull line from the reel without breaking it. Conventional reels often have a more powerful drag system suited for larger fish, while spinning reels typically feature a front or rear drag system that offers ease of adjustment and fine-tuning during the fight.
Line Capacity: When selecting a reel, consider the line capacity, as trolling for larger fish often means using heavier lines that require more spool space. Conventional reels generally have a higher line capacity, which is essential for deep-sea fishing, while spinning reels may be limited in this aspect but can still handle lighter lines effectively for various species.
What Size Trolling Fishing Reel Is Ideal for Different Fishing Conditions?
Choosing the right size trolling fishing reel depends on various fishing conditions and target species.
- Small Reels (100-300 yards capacity): Ideal for inshore trolling and targeting smaller species like mackerel or trout.
- Medium Reels (300-600 yards capacity): Suitable for offshore fishing and can handle medium to large species such as tuna or wahoo.
- Large Reels (600+ yards capacity): Best for deep-sea fishing where large pelagic species like marlin or swordfish are targeted.
- Level Wind Reels: Convenient for beginners, these reels automatically guide the line back and forth across the spool for even line distribution.
- Conventional Reels: Preferred by experienced anglers, they offer better control and durability when fighting larger fish.
Small reels are perfect for lighter tackle setups and allow for quick adjustments while fishing in calmer waters, making them versatile for various inshore applications.
Medium reels provide a balance between line capacity and drag power, making them versatile for both inshore and offshore trolling, accommodating a range of species effectively.
Large reels are specifically designed for heavy-duty fishing in deep waters where resistance from larger fish requires more line capacity and stronger drag systems to manage long runs.
Level wind reels simplify the reeling process, ensuring that the line is evenly distributed across the spool, which can be especially beneficial for novice anglers still mastering the technique.
Conventional reels, on the other hand, are robust and allow for precise control, giving experienced anglers the advantage needed to battle larger game fish effectively.
What Are the Most Trusted Brands in Trolling Fishing Reels?
The most trusted brands in trolling fishing reels are recognized for their quality, durability, and performance in various fishing conditions.
- Shimano: Shimano is known for its innovative technology and high-quality craftsmanship in fishing reels. Their trolling reels, such as the Tiagra series, are favored for their smooth drag systems and reliable performance, making them ideal for both saltwater and freshwater fishing.
- Penn: Penn has a long-standing reputation for producing durable and powerful fishing reels. The Penn International series is particularly popular among serious anglers for its strength and ability to handle large catches, with features like a robust drag system and corrosion-resistant materials.
- Abu Garcia: Abu Garcia combines cutting-edge technology with ergonomic design in their trolling reels. The Revo series is highly regarded for its lightweight construction and advanced braking systems, providing anglers with precision and control during their fishing expeditions.
- Okuma: Okuma is known for offering a wide range of affordable yet reliable fishing reels. Their Cold Water line is specifically designed for trolling, featuring a durable construction and smooth drag system, making it a favorite among both novice and experienced anglers.
- Daiwa: Daiwa is celebrated for its innovative designs and high-performance reels. The Saltiga series, for instance, offers exceptional strength and durability, making it suitable for serious trolling in tough ocean conditions, with features that enhance casting distance and accuracy.
How Much Should You Expect to Spend on Quality Trolling Fishing Reels?
The cost of quality trolling fishing reels can vary significantly based on brand, features, and materials used, typically ranging from $50 to over $500.
- Entry-Level Reels ($50 – $150): These reels are generally made from durable materials, suitable for beginners or casual anglers. They often come with basic features that are sufficient for light to moderate trolling, making them a great option for those not ready to invest heavily.
- Mid-Range Reels ($150 – $300): Mid-range trolling reels offer a balance of performance and affordability, featuring better construction, smoother drag systems, and enhanced gear ratios. These reels are ideal for more serious anglers who fish regularly and require reliable and efficient equipment without breaking the bank.
- High-End Reels ($300 – $500+): High-end trolling reels are constructed with advanced materials and technology, providing superior performance and durability. These reels often include features like precision engineering, advanced drag systems, and increased line capacity, perfect for professional anglers or those targeting larger species in demanding conditions.
- Specialty Reels ($500 and up): These are top-of-the-line reels designed for specific trolling applications, such as deep-sea fishing. They often come with custom features tailored to particular fishing styles and can handle the most challenging conditions, making them an investment for serious sport fishermen.
What Do User Reviews Tell Us About the Best Trolling Fishing Reels?
User reviews provide valuable insights into the best trolling fishing reels by highlighting performance, durability, and user satisfaction.
- Durability: Many users emphasize the importance of a reel’s construction materials, such as stainless steel or aluminum, which can withstand harsh marine environments. A durable reel not only lasts longer but also maintains consistent performance over time, making it a worthwhile investment for avid anglers.
- Smooth Drag System: Reviewers often mention the significance of a smooth drag system in trolling fishing reels. A reliable drag system allows for better control when reeling in fish, reducing the risk of line breakage or losing the catch, which is crucial during extended trolling sessions.
- Gear Ratio: Users frequently discuss the gear ratio of a reel, which affects how quickly line can be retrieved. Higher gear ratios are preferred for fast retrieves, while lower ratios provide more torque for battling larger fish, giving anglers the ability to choose a reel that fits their specific fishing style.
- Line Capacity: Many reviews point out the importance of line capacity, as it determines how much line can be stored on the reel. A reel with adequate line capacity is essential for targeting larger species that require longer runs without the risk of running out of line.
- Ease of Use: User feedback often highlights the ease of use of various trolling reels, including features like ergonomic handles and intuitive drag adjustments. A user-friendly design can enhance the overall fishing experience, especially for beginners or those fishing for extended periods.
- Price vs. Value: Reviewers frequently evaluate the price point of trolling reels in relation to their performance and features. Many anglers agree that a higher price does not always guarantee better quality, and finding a reel that offers excellent value for money is a common theme in user reviews.
- Brand Reputation: Users often refer to trusted brands with a history of producing reliable fishing gear. Established brands typically have a loyal customer base, and positive reviews can serve as a reassurance of the product’s quality and performance.
How Can You Maintain and Care for Your Trolling Fishing Reel?
Maintaining and caring for your trolling fishing reel is essential for ensuring its longevity and optimal performance. Here are some crucial steps to follow:
-
Regular Cleaning: After each fishing outing, rinse your reel with fresh water to remove salt, dirt, and debris. Use a soft cloth to wipe down the exterior, ensuring no residue remains.
-
Lubrication: Apply the appropriate reel grease and oil to bearings, gears, and other moving parts periodically. This prevents corrosion and reduces friction, which can enhance your reel’s efficiency.
-
Check Drag System: Regularly inspect the drag system for smooth operation. Adjust the drag settings slowly to avoid over-tightening, which can lead to gear damage.
-
Inspect Line and Spool: Replace worn or frayed fishing line. Check the spool for any signs of wear, as a damaged spool can affect casting and line retrieval.
-
Storage: Store your reel in a cool, dry place when not in use. Avoid leaving it in direct sunlight, as UV exposure can damage components.
-
Professional Servicing: Consider servicing your reel annually or bi-annually, depending on usage. A professional can help address internal issues that might not be visible externally.
By following these maintenance tips, you can extend the life of your trolling fishing reel and enjoy a more successful fishing experience.
Related Post: